Back to The Decalogy
Source correctionResearch comparison

Mortal Computation:Two Research Traditions

A careful comparison of Alexander Ororbia and Karl Friston’s embodied-intelligence review, Geoffrey Hinton’s hardware-learning proposal, and the Decalogy’s interpretive questions about material conditions, feedback, and human agency.

Read this page accurately

The same phrase names two different arguments

The exact title Mortal Computation: A Foundation for Biomimetic Intelligence belongs to a 2023–24 review by Alexander Ororbia and Karl Friston. Geoffrey Hinton’s 2022 paper is titled The Forward-Forward Algorithm: Some Preliminary Investigations; it contains a distinct section called “Mortal Computation.” These sources are related by vocabulary, not by authorship or scope.

Exact paper title

Ororbia & Friston, 2023–24

A theoretical review of embodied and biomimetic intelligence. It uses biophysics, cybernetics, Markov blankets, inference, learning, and selection to frame mortal computation.

Read the paper on arXiv

Separate use of the term

Hinton, 2022

A paper introducing the Forward-Forward learning procedure. Its “Mortal Computation” section considers hardware-specific learning, low-power analog hardware, and knowledge transfer by distillation.

Read the paper on arXiv

Source boundary

Neither paper establishes that present AI systems are conscious, that future AI will necessarily be conscious, that intelligence follows one inevitable evolutionary route, or that humans must be subordinated by machines. The Decalogy’s wider reading is an interpretation; it is not an empirical conclusion supplied by either paper.

Sources and related reading

  1. [1]Alexander Ororbia and Karl Friston, “Mortal Computation: A Foundation for Biomimetic Intelligence” (2023–24)
  2. [2]Geoffrey Hinton, “The Forward-Forward Algorithm: Some Preliminary Investigations” (2022)
  3. [3]Denis Noble, “A theory of biological relativity: no privileged level of causation” (2011)— background reading on multi-level biological causation; it is not evidence about machine consciousness.

Share a source-disciplined comparison

This page separates two uses of “mortal computation” before asking what either can contribute to a wider discussion of embodiment, learning, and technical dependency.

Discussion

Share your thoughts and engage with the community

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!